In the quest for a thriving workplace, understanding the dynamics that foster collaboration and growth is as crucial as identifying those that hinder it. Criticism, Defensiveness, Contempt, and Stonewalling are dynamics that hinder team collaboration and growth. Organization and Relationship Systems Coaching (ORSC) refers to the behaviors as “Team Toxins,” which are based on the Gottman Institute's "Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse" concept. This post explores its relevance in professional settings, highlighting strategies to navigate and neutralize these behaviors for a healthier work environment. 

Addressing these behaviors head-on is not merely about preventing conflict; it's about laying the foundation for an inclusive culture where every team member feels valued, understood, and empowered to contribute their best. This is the cornerstone upon which innovative, resilient, and harmonious work environments are built. By tackling these toxins, we open the door to cultivating a workplace where inclusion, belonging, and well-being principles are celebrated as ideals and actively practiced and woven into daily interactions. Read on to explore each Team Toxin and share actionable insights for fostering a collaborative, inclusive, and vibrant workplace.

Transforming Team Toxins into Pathways for Growth

Transforming team dynamics involves recognizing and addressing challenges with compassionate and constructive strategies. This approach fosters an environment of growth, collaboration, and resilience. Below each description of the team toxin, we list practices that pave the way for a workplace where collaboration thrives on respect, openness, and mutual appreciation.

  1. Transforming Criticism into Constructive Engagement: Criticism, especially when it feels personal, can diminish trust and openness, which are vital for team synergy. Transitioning to specific, actionable feedback fosters a culture of support and mutual respect. To cultivate this environment:
    1. Initiate a Culture of Appreciation: Begin meetings with acknowledgments of individual contributions. This positive foundation makes constructive feedback more acceptable and effective.
    2. Separate the Behavior from the Person: Encourage feedback focusing on tasks or behaviors rather than personal attributes. For instance, suggest improvements by saying, "Let's explore how we can enhance the accuracy of this report together," promoting a collaborative and solution-focused mindset.
  2. Overcoming Defensiveness with Vulnerability and Openness: Defensiveness, while a natural reaction, can obstruct productive dialogue and problem-solving. Creating a culture that views feedback as an opportunity for growth rather than criticism encourages open, productive dialogue. Strategies include:
    1. Encourage Sharing of Mistakes: Facilitate sessions where team members share mistakes and learning outcomes, demonstrating that mistakes are growth opportunities, not personal shortcomings.
    2. Develop Active Listening: Invest in developing listening skills within the team to ensure members feel heard and valued, enhancing the team's overall communication and problem-solving abilities.
  3. Addressing Contempt with Empathy and Respect: Contempt, manifesting as sarcasm or dismissiveness, undermines team cohesion. Fostering an environment of respect and appreciation for diverse perspectives is essential. Action steps include:
    1. Implement Restorative Engagement Practices: Foster a framework that emphasizes open dialogue, education on respect and cultural sensitivity, and the use of restorative practices to address and heal instances of disrespect, ensuring multiple supportive channels for safely voicing concerns.
    2. Promote Empathy and Role Understanding: Engage the team in exercises that enhance understanding of each other's roles, challenges, and contributions, enriching empathy and mutual respect.
  4. Breaking Down Stonewalling with Engagement and Dialogue: Stonewalling, or withdrawing from communication, obstructs team collaboration. Encouraging engagement and ensuring equitable participation can dismantle barriers to effective teamwork. Practices to enhance participation:
    1. Ensure Equitable Voice: Integrate practices like round-robin check-ins at meetings to allow everyone to share their thoughts and concerns, promoting a culture of inclusivity and engagement.
    2. Equip with Conflict Resolution Tools: Provide training or workshops on constructive conflict engagement, empowering team members to navigate and resolve disputes effectively.

Transforming team dynamics from toxic to collaborative requires recognizing the issues and committing to sustained change and growth. Understanding and addressing team toxins will foster a culture of open communication, mutual respect, and continuous improvement. This effort benefits the organizational climate and contributes to each team member's personal and professional development.

Further Exploration

The Gottman Institute | A research-based approach to relationships
The Gottman Institute. A research-based approach to relationships. Explore our resources and tools developed by Drs. John and Julie Gottman.
The Gottman InstituteEllie Lisitsa
Organization and Relationship Systems Coaching (ORSC )
Learn about Organization and Relationship Systems Coaching (ORSC), a groundbreaking accredited training program for coaching teams, families & organizations
CRR Global
Dare to Lead
#1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER • Brené Brown has taught us what it means to dare greatly, rise strong, and brave the wilderness. Now, based on new research conducted with leaders, change makers, and culture shifters, she’s showing us how to put those ideas into practice so we can step up and lead.Don’t miss the five-part Max docuseries Brené Brown: Atlas of the Heart!ONE OF BLOOMBERG’S BEST BOOKS OF THE YEARLeadership is not about titles, status, and wielding power. A leader is anyone who takes responsibility for recognizing the potential in people and ideas, and has the courage to develop that potential.When we dare to lead, we don’t pretend to have the right answers; we stay curious and ask the right questions. We don’t see power as finite and hoard it; we know that power becomes infinite when we share it with others. We don’t avoid difficult conversations and situations; we lean into vulnerability when it’s necessary to do good work.But daring leadership in a culture defined by scarcity, fear, and uncertainty requires skill-building around traits that are deeply and uniquely human. The irony is that we’re choosing not to invest in developing the hearts and minds of leaders at the exact same time as we’re scrambling to figure out what we have to offer that machines and AI can’t do better and faster. What can we do better? Empathy, connection, and courage, to start.Four-time #1 New York Times bestselling author Brené Brown has spent the past two decades studying the emotions and experiences that give meaning to our lives, and the past seven years working with transformative leaders and teams spanning the globe. She found that leaders in organizations ranging from small entrepreneurial startups and family-owned businesses to nonprofits, civic organizations, and Fortune 50 companies all ask the same question:How do you cultivate braver, more daring leaders, and how do you embed the value of courage in your culture?In Dare to Lead, Brown uses research, stories, and examples to answer these questions in the no-BS style that millions of readers have come to expect and love.Brown writes, “One of the most important findings of my career is that daring leadership is a collection of four skill sets that are 100 percent teachable, observable, and measurable. It’s learning and unlearning that requires brave work, tough conversations, and showing up with your whole heart. Easy? No. Because choosing courage over comfort is not always our default. Worth it? Always. We want to be brave with our lives and our work. It’s why we’re here.”Whether you’ve read Daring Greatly and Rising Strong or you’re new to Brené Brown’s work, this book is for anyone who wants to step up and into brave leadership.
Google Books
The Fearless Organization
Conquer the most essential adaptation to the knowledge economy The Fearless Organization: Creating Psychological Safety in the Workplace for Learning, Innovation, and Growth offers practical guidance for teams and organizations who are serious about success in the modern economy. With so much riding on innovation, creativity, and spark, it is essential to attract and retain quality talent—but what good does this talent do if no one is able to speak their mind? The traditional culture of “fitting in” and “going along” spells doom in the knowledge economy. Success requires a continuous influx of new ideas, new challenges, and critical thought, and the interpersonal climate must not suppress, silence, ridicule or intimidate. Not every idea is good, and yes there are stupid questions, and yes dissent can slow things down, but talking through these things is an essential part of the creative process. People must be allowed to voice half-finished thoughts, ask questions from left field, and brainstorm out loud; it creates a culture in which a minor flub or momentary lapse is no big deal, and where actual mistakes are owned and corrected, and where the next left-field idea could be the next big thing. This book explores this culture of psychological safety, and provides a blueprint for bringing it to life. The road is sometimes bumpy, but succinct and informative scenario-based explanations provide a clear path forward to constant learning and healthy innovation. Explore the link between psychological safety and high performance Create a culture where it’s “safe” to express ideas, ask questions, and admit mistakes Nurture the level of engagement and candor required in today’s knowledge economy Follow a step-by-step framework for establishing psychological safety in your team or organization Shed the “yes-men” approach and step into real performance. Fertilize creativity, clarify goals, achieve accountability, redefine leadership, and much more. The Fearless Organization helps you bring about this most critical transformation.
Google Books